 On March 11, 2010 it was announced that Sutton had signed with the New York Red Bulls.On April 27, 2010 Sutton officially debuted for New York in a 2-1 victory over Philadelphia Union in a 2010 Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup qualification match.On August 11, 2010 Sutton made his league debut for New York recording a 1-0 shutout over his former club Toronto FC.