 Weezer incorrectly referred to it as having been performed by Debbie Gibson, who performed a similar style of pop music and was popular during the same time as Tiffany.Rivers Cuomo admitted that he noticed the mistake while writing the song, but left it in the finished song.Tiffany and Tobin made no attempt to contrast the verses and the refrain, as James and the Shondells had, instead keeping the "peppy" arrangements they used all throughout her recording and performances.