 Andy was signed by Shamrock Rovers from Longford Town in July 2006 making his debut against Galway United on 4 August.Always a Rovers fan, Andy broke into the top 20 all time League of Ireland goal scorers in August 2007.His hat-trick on 14 September against Galway United brought his all-time league total to 129 goals

In his career he has been top scorer in the League of Ireland First Division for two seasons in 1999–2000 and 2000–01.