 In that case, Tenise Barker, a 29-year-old nursing student in the Bronx, moved to dismiss the RIAA's complaint for lack of specificity, and on the ground that merely "making available" does not constitute a copyright infringement.In opposing Ms. Barker's motion, the RIAA argued that "making available" is indeed a copyright infringement.Upon learning of the RIAA's argument, which sought to expand copyright law, the Computer & Communications Industry Association, the U.S. Internet Industry Association, and the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) submitted "amicus curiae" briefs supporting Ms. Barker's motion and rebutting the RIAA's argument.