 Subsequently in 2009, she created the role of Charlotte in the new musical "Through the Door" by British composer/lyricist Laurence Mark Wythe and American bookwriter Judy Freed, at the Trafalgar Studios in a West End production.In 2010 she appeared in the musical "Tomorrow Morning" at the Landor Theatre in South London, the award winning musical by Laurence Mark Wythe.During the months of February and March 2011, Atherton starred alongside her "Avenue Q" castmate, Daniel Boys, in "Ordinary Days" at the Trafalgar Studios.