 In UMG v. Lindor, the defendant argued that the RIAA's damage theory was unconstitutional because it sought 1071 times the actual
cost per track in online stores ($.70).After a Brooklyn Federal Court judge upheld the legal theory behind the RIAA's assessment of damages in November 2006, UMG dropped the lawsuit.In 2008, federal judge Xavier Rodriguez ruled that teenager Whitney Harper would only have to pay $200 in damages per song that she shared on the KaZaA network, instead of the $750 per song that the RIAA was seeking.