 He handled punting and kick-off duties for the Colts in 2009, as well as holding for extra-points and field goals, a position he had never played before.In 2009 McAfee helped Indianapolis win the AFC South, the AFC Championship, and helped the Colts reach Super Bowl XLIV.McAfee maintained a 46.6-yard punting average for the 2011 regular season, a mark he would better the following season by posting a 48.2-yard average on punts.