 Reyes posted a record of 7-3 during the 2007 season, including 2 games (2 victories) during the College World Series; the first one, a victory against Cal State Fullerton and the second one, a victory in the first game of the Championship Finals against the University of North Carolina.His ERA for the season was 3.10.In 2008, he played collegiate summer baseball for the Falmouth Commodores of the Cape Cod Baseball League, then returned to the league in 2009 to play for the Orleans Firebirds.