 Alton Ellis' version was originally produced as a one-man song, but he later teamed up with his sister, Hortense Ellis to perform a duet.It wasn't until this moment that the song showed a romantic battle between two parties to continue a seemingly ruined relationship.Hortense Ellis also did her own version of her brother's song entitled "I'm Still In Love with You (Boy)", which was later done by Marcia Aitken.