 According to Mario Mesquita Borges of AllMusic, Midnight Syndicate typically create "darkly blended compositions", described both as "gloomy" and "brooding".Leonard Pickel of "Haunted Attraction Magazine" stated that "each year, the band's music becomes more a part of America's Halloween culture", and stated that the band had "literally formed their own musical genre".For Douglas, however, "Dungeons & Dragons" was a different style of music from other albums and soundtracks that the band had produced.