 His batting average in the minor leagues was .291.His most productive year as a baseball player was 1913 when he compiled a .345 batting average, .552 slugging percentage and 57 extra base hits in 115 games with the Fort Wayne Champs.Tutwiler was married to Edna Mae Scruggs, and they had two sons, Guy Tutwiler, Jr. and Pickens McQueen Tutwiler.