 Tutwiler appeared in 27 major league games, including 14 as a first baseman, six as a second baseman, and three as an outfielder.In his major league career, Tutwiler had a batting average of .203 with 16 hits, seven runs scored, 10 runs batted in, six walks, 12 doubles, two stolen bases, and one triple.He also played 13 seasons in the minor leagues, including stints with the Hattiesburg Timberjacks (1910-1911), Chattanooga Lookouts (1912), Providence Grays (1912, 1914-1917), Mobile Bears (1919-1920), Little Rock Travelers (1921), Memphis Chickasaws (1922), and Augusta Tygers (1924).