 He appeared in 113 games as an outfielder for the 1892 Colts and compiled a .284 batting average with 19 doubles, 7 triples, and 15 stolen bases.Dungan remained with the Colts in 1893, appearing in 107 games as an outfielder, raising his batting average to .297 with 23 doubles and 7 triples.His 138 hits in 1893 was second to Bill Dahlen on the 1893 Colts.