 Alfie left at the end of the season to re-join his first English club, Rotherham Titans, who were playing in the 2013–14 RFU Championship stating that he was delighted to return to the club "where he had the happiest time of his career".He had a run of games in the Titans squad and helped them to 4th place in the league and qualifying for the promotion playoffs.He played in the two semi final matches against former club Bristol but was unable to prevent his team from losing both games, ending any dreams of taking the Championship title.