 Philibert de Bruillard, Bishop of Grenoble November 16, 1851 under the title of Our Lady of La Salette.Both secrets were written down by the visionaries and sent to the pope in the same year.Sociologist Michael P. Carroll hypothesizes that the apparition may have grown out of an initial hallucination, shaped by an unconscious desire on the part of Maximin to punish his step-mother for mistreating him.