 On 19 September 2012, Felgueiras put on a "Player of the match" performance against former side Braga, in a 2–0 Champions League group stage away win, being subsequently selected for the Team of the Round.In the same competition, he was also in goal to help to a 1–0 triumph over Manchester United at Old Trafford, being subsequently linked to Premier League's Everton as a backup to Tim Howard and commenting