 In the fourth, a right from Duffy sent Murphy down for a long count of twelve, and when he arose, Duffy put him to the mat four additional times.In a bout with Charles Gleason, on January 7, 1889, Duffy was given "the fight of his life", in a ten round points decision in Boston.The official ruling was a draw, but Gleason proved a hard hitter and a clever sparrer and was game throughout the match.