 Anna's account was contested by the editors of "The Northern Psalter", who wrote to Monteith claiming that she had confused the tune with another entitled that Jessie had composed and submitted to them for publication.After the account provided by Anna's letter was published in the "Bulletin of the Hymn Society" and "The Scotsman" newspaper, many hymnals began to credit Irvine instead of Grant as the composer, and the hymn is now regularly — but not universally — attributed to Jessie Seymour Irvine.Anna's claim has latterly been disputed by some scholars who favour Grant, and some hymnals still credit Grant as the composer.