 NY 267 was assigned to a routing extending from NY 93 in Akron to the Erie–Genesee county line by way of John Street and Bloomingdale Road.Farther east, the portion of Bloomingdale Road between the Tonawanda Indian Reservation and NY 77 was designated as NY 77A around the same time.NY 77A and the remainder of Bloomingdale Road within Genesee County became an extension of NY 267 in the late 1930s.