 In a decision dated April 23, 2009, the Supreme Administrative Court rejected the appeal, confirming the decision of the lower court.The municipal election in Perpignan was officially cancelled and a new election was organized.On , the "Perpignan at Heart" list led by Alduy in the new municipal elections was first in the first round of voting with 40.35% of the vote, beating the "left list"'s 24.75% and the former deputy Jean Codognes.