 On November 28, 1932 the Appellate Division of the New York State Supreme Court reversed a ruling for plaintiff and former Schenectady, New York fireman, James Eagan.Earlier Eagan sued and won $32,5000 from the Luxor Hotel and Baths for personal injuries he sustained on December 5, 1930.He claimed that the hotel was negligent in posting no warning signs to indicate that the pool was only partially filled, at the time he dived in.