 Reviews of "Cheater, Cheater" have been positive.Roughstock.com said that "'Cheater, Cheater' is an honest-to-God pure country song that jumps out of the speakers.With lyrics that find Joey as the woman who's been cheated on… [i]t’s three minutes of tempo and while it remains to be seen whether radio will embrace this truly country duo, songs like 'Cheater, Cheater"'are what makes country music what it is