 Subsequently, in April 2008, the Bundestag (German parliament) approved a new law requiring ISPs to divulge the identity of suspected infringers who infringe on a commercial scale.In Spain the Spanish Supreme Court recently ruled that personal data associated with an IP address could only be disclosed in the course of a criminal investigation or for public safety reasons ("Productores de Música de España v. Telefónica de España SAU").In Italy courts established that criminally liability does not extend to file sharing copyrighted material, as long as it is not done for commercial gain.