 Calling Cook "delightfully" country, Paulette Flowers said she released "genuine Grade-A country" music.Larry Aydlette said although Cook may seem like an attempt to mimic Shania Twain, she is set apart by her "healthy respect for serious country music" as shown by her choice to cover "I'm Not Lisa" and include Bill Anderson on "Don't Bother Me".While describing Cook's voice as having a "Dolly Parton sweetness", Patrick Langston commended her for being able to convey more emotions than Twain.