 Colchester then introduced midfielder Chris Fry for defender Paul Gibbs at half-time in extra time, but as penalties loomed, Colchester had a great opportunity to win the game.Just fifteen seconds from time, Mark Sale's cross reached full-back Joe Dunne at the far-post, but he put his shot high over the bar.In the shoot-out, Colchester captain Richard Wilkins stepped up to convert the first spot-kick, before Carlisle's Paul Conway equalised.