 All four wins by the 2019 Argos came with Bethel-Thompson starting at quarterback, and by the end of the season, Bethel-Thompson's career year had produced a CFL best 26 touchdown passes.During his first three years in the CFL, Bethel-Thompson had also been working towards his master's degree in education from UC Berkeley.The day before he defended his thesis, Bethel-Thompson signed an extension with Toronto.