 Sprenkel signed with USL PRO side Antigua Barracuda FC and made his professional debut in a 1–0 loss against the Orange County Blues.Later in 2012 he signed a two-year contract with Chicago Soul between 2012–13 before returning to in Greenscastle, Indiana to become an assistant coach for DePauw's soccer team.The Zionsville native signed with his home team, the Indy Eleven, on November 11, 2013.