 The song was mastered by David Kutch at The Mastering Palace, New York City, New York.Adam Markovitz of "Entertainment Weekly" awarded "Dear Future Husband" an "A−" rating in a review of the "Title" EP, and deemed it an "irresistible" sock hop throwback.Chris DeVille of Stereogum wrote that "Dear Future Husband" was interchangeable in its lyrical content in comparison with the EP's title track.