 Melanie J. Sims of the Associated Press felt that "Like I'm Gonna Lose You" was the "most refreshing" track on "Title", and deemed it "a nice change of pace sonically".Glenn Gamboa of "Newsday" called the song "classic-sounding" and said that it would stick with Trainor throughout her "sure-to-be-lengthy" career.Martin Townsend of the "Daily Express" named "Like I'm Gonna Lose You", along with "Walkashame", as the album's best tracks.