 They re-joined the Yackandandah Football League (formally known by "Yackandandah Football Association") for the 1945 season.They competed in the league until 1952 when they decide to leave Yackandandah Football League in favor of joining the neighbouring Tallangatta And District Football League, and within just three short year the ""Yackandandah Football League"" had folded due to lack of clubs.The club was an early powerhouse in its new league, becoming the first club to achieve a three-peat of premierships (1955-1956-1957), a record only equaled by Mitta United (1959-1960-1961).