 During this time they competed in two Grand Finals, the 1928 YFA-B Grade Grand Final where they were defeated by Yackandandah at Sandy Creek, and the 1937 DDFA Grand Final where they were defeated by Kiewa (10.5.65 - 11.9.75).Before the 1940 season Kergunyah went into recess due to a lack of number because of the ongoing War, they continued to be in a state of recess until the 1944 post season.The club was re-activated during the 1945 pre-season, they continued to be based in the small township of Kergunyah, Victoria and chose to ""Red and White colours"" for its playing jumpers.