 On 27 February 2011, Sutton scored twice as Motherwell shocked Celtic 2–0 at Fir Park, and on 16 April 2011, he scored a screaming half volley from outside the box in the Scottish Cup Semi-Final against St Johnstone.His final appearance for Motherwell came in the 2011 Scottish Cup Final, losing 3–0 to Celtic at Hampden Park.He finished the season as their top scorer with 17 goals.