 On 4 August 2012, Sutton scored from the penalty spot in a 2–0 win over St Johnstone.After Hearts entered administration in June 2013, Sutton was made redundant by the club as he refused to accept a pay cut.Following his departure, Sutton explained that he had been told by Hearts that he didn't feature in their future plans, insisting he was no traitor to the club, and admitted joining the club was a mistake in the first place.