 Sutton's penalty miss did not matter at all, as "Well" blew the Albanians away in the second leg at Fir Park, winning 8–1, although Sutton did not score in this match either, nor did he score in either leg of the third qualifying round tie with Steaua Bucureşti, as Motherwell lost 3–0 in Romania and 3–1 at home to go out 6–1 on aggregate.Sutton netted a brace in the historic 6–6 draw with Hibernian on 5 May 2010.He finished the 2009–10 season with a total of 14 goals in 38 appearances.