 Two weeks later, on 28 September 2013, he scored his first brace of the season, as Motherwell won 2–0 against Ross County and he scored another against Ross County on 14 December 2013, in a 2–1 win for Motherwell.After sixteen goals in twenty league appearances, in March 2014, manager Stuart McCall described Sutton as the key signing of the season.Sutton was involved in the 92nd minute winning goal from Craig Reid in the 1–0 league victory at Aberdeen on the last day of the 2013–14 league season on 11 May 2014, a victory which seen Motherwell secure second spot for the second season running, leapfrogging Aberdeen in the process.