 St. Andrews debuted in 1907 against the Vale of Atholl in front of 1000 spectators at University Park.The club have appeared in the Scottish Cup proper on three occasions losing 10–1 to Cowdenbeath in 1923, 3–;0 at home to Bathgate in 1929 and 6–1 away to Nithsdale Wanderers in 1930.There are no records of the club's exploits in the Scottish Amateur Cup, but the university side have won the Fife Amateur Cup on three occasions –1934-35, 1957-58, and more recently in 2018-2019.