 Their most successful season to date was 2003–04 where they were 'promoted' to division 1 via a restructuring of the league and they won the Division 2 Cup, defeating Inverkeithing Swifts in the final 2–1.The club entered a third team into the Saturday Amateur League for the first time in 2005, under the banner of St. Andrews Academicals.After two disappointing seasons, the club decided to stop fielding Academicals in the Fife League.