 The couple welcomed a son, Caleb David Gethard, in April 2019.He is an avid fan of The Smiths and has two tattoos related to the band—Morrissey's signature on his right shoulder (based on an actual signature he got in marker on his arm), and "It takes strength to be gentle and kind," a lyric from "I Know It's Over," on his right biceps.Gethard has stated that his favorite sport is basketball and he is a New York Knicks fan.