 Cummins collected his second Munster medal that day, however, Tipperary were subsequently defeated in a tense All-Ireland semi-final by Waterford on a scoreline of 1-20 to 1-18.Cummins was once again presented with an All-Star award.In 2009 Cummins won his third Munster medal as Tipp defeated Waterford by 4-14 to 2-16.