 On 3 September 2006 Hindmarch, aged 16 years and 291 days old and a first year YTS player was on the substitutes bench for the game against Cheltenham Town (he was given the squad number 28) after Michael Bridges moved on to Hull City and scoring against Bury's reserve team on 30 August 2006 the game finished 3–3.this was only Hindmarch's fourth reserve match.United manager Neil McDonald who was at the game was impressed with the goal.