 Paige appeared in touring productions of musicals such as "Annie Get Your Gun", "Applause", "Sweet Charity", "Ballroom", "", and "Guys and Dolls".In 1984, she was back on Broadway with Kevin McCarthy in a nonmusical play, "Alone Together" The tryout tour gave Paige her first experience of the eastern summer-sStock circuit, where she said audiences "laughed so hard you just had to wait", and she enjoyed the role so much, she played it again in 1988 at the Coconut Grove Playhouse, this time with Robert Reed.During the 1955–1956 television season, Paige starred in her own CBS situation comedy, "It's Always Jan," co-starring Merry Anders, as Janis Stewart, a widowed mother, and her two female roommates played by Anders and Patricia Bright.