 A reviewer for "Next Generation" called the game ""NBA Jam" on ice", and said it would be particularly appreciated since arcade hockey games were almost unheard of at the time.He applauded the game's full NHL licensing and player rosters, flaming pucks, two-on-two mode, commentary, and overall depth and playability of its hockey action, and concluded that "Williams rarely makes a bad move, and "Open Ice" is testament to its conservative but consistent quality games.