 "The Massachusetts Daily Collegian" gave a favourable review, calling the album "a crystalline example of the heights that teen pop can accomplish".Karen Tye spoke favourably of the album, saying they had "ditched the cutesy voices and effervescent ditties" and replaced it with acoustic pop and rock which occasionally bordered on country.She praised M2M for using "down-to-earhtunes and thoughtful lyrics" instead of revealing outfits to propel them into the limelight, unlike many of their pop counterparts.