 Patsy Morita, reviewing Herrick's 1990 recording of Bach's Toccatas and Fugues (part of his complete organ works of Bach for Hyperion), writes that he chooses "a more conservative approach" to make the music more like what it would have been on a Bach-era organ.The "famous Toccata and Fugue", BWV 565, is "therefore, not the blusterous piece that many recognize.It's a more thoughtful and considered reading."