 He was on a half forward flank in their 1919 premiership but was used mostly as a defender.His other Grand Final appearances came in 1920, 1922, 1925 and 1926 while he was a half back flanker in the Collingwood premiership team of 1927.He could have added another in 1928, but lost his place in the side after the drawn semi final against Melbourne which would be his last game.