 He only played a few games for Dundee before transferring to Dundee Hibernian (Dundee United's name until 1923).He made his debut for Dundee Hibs on 16 August 1913 and in his first season scored 22 goals in Scottish Division 2, becoming the division's top scorer for 1913–14.In his next season with Dundee Hibs he was again Scottish Division 2 top scorer, this time with 30 goals, scoring 5 in one game against Albion Rovers.