 On June 1, 2010, Wagenfuhr again became a free agent upon the dissolution of the Athletica.She later signed with the Littleton, Colorado-based Colorado Rush of the W-League, the second tier of American women's soccer.Wagenfuhr assisted on the game-winning goal in the expansion side's first ever victory, a 2-0 triumph over the Santa Clarita Blue Heat on June 24, 2010.