 The artwork for the single and the EP, both designed by Katie Waronker's company Riot Structure, blended Hawaiian-inspired imagery including Presley's 1961 LP "Blue Hawaii" as inspiration for the "Merry Christmas Baby" cover art, and a depiction of Kalakaua Blvd in Waikiki (with Los Angeles-inspired billboards featuring Loren, photographed by Mark Arbeit) for the cover of the EP.The back of the EP includes a picture of Loren from the 1960s.Further links between Presley and Loren include Presley's recording "I Believe" for his EP "Peace in the Valley" in 1957, a song Loren also recorded at Capitol, and which she regularly performed.