 On 3 April 2013, he scored his first goal in Chiefs colours against Maritzburg United in a 1–1 draw.He won the 2012/13 league title and the Nedbank Cup in his first season.Mathoho made his CAF Champions League debut on 1 March 2014 and scored against Liga Muculmana in a 4–0 win at Moses Mabhida Stadium on what was his 24th birthday.