 She was cast as the female lead in the Broadway musical "Bombay Dreams" as Priya during her second year at NYU.She married actor Aalok Mehta, who co-starred in the musical.Nagarajan appeared in a number of regional theater productions following "Bombay Dreams", including the Hangar Theater production of "Rent" in Ithaca, New York and "The Wiz" at the La Jolla Playhouse in San Diego, California.