 He was not "overly blown away" with Liz's plot, but said it redeemed itself at the end "by providing another nice moment of connection" between the Jack and Liz characters.Rabin gave "Reaganing" a B+ grade, praising the (non-existent) scene where Jack put pills into Tracy's jelly beans.Samantha Urban of "The Dallas Morning News" said that the best part of the episode was Jack McBrayer's Kenneth "actually [having] some funny lines for the first time ."