 On December 19, 2018, Reynolds announced his retirement from competitive skating.In a statement, Reynolds said, “Despite an encouraging start to the season with a new personal best short program, I was unable maintain this form and my body has started to tell me it has had enough.It was a tough decision but given the circumstances I know it is the right choice.”

His favorite quad is the salchow, which he first landed at 15, and he has also practiced a quad loop.