 H. Grätz goes farthest of all, by simply identifying the Babylon of the midrash with Rome, and the fights of Gog and Magog described in the work with the devastating invasion of the Hungarians into Italy from 889 to 955.The most radical opponent of this view is M. Friedmann.For him all arguments concerning the age of the "Tanna debe Eliyahu" and against its identification with the ""Seder Eliyahu"" mentioned in "Ket."