 The Appeals Chamber found that it was not shown that Boškoskihad failed to take the necessary and reasonable measures to punish his offending subordinates.The Chamber stated that, in the circumstances of the case, it was open to a reasonable trier of fact to acquit Boškoski of failure to punish, on the basis of reports about the events described in the indictment which had been provided by the Ministry of Interior to the competent judicial authorities.The Appeals Chamber dismissed the Prosecution's single ground of appeal against Boškoski’s acquittal.