 Injuries and a lack of playing time hampered his ascension to becoming a prominent figure in Israeli football, and most of his career he bounced around between relegation bound clubs in the Israeli Premier League and clubs who were trying to get promotion from Liga Leumit.On June 25, 2012 Nagar signed with Maccabi Yavne, he played there for 3 years.In the middle of the 2014-15 season, Nagar started to work as the CEO of the club.