 Chorlton followed that up with an ever-present season in 1909–10, the only Red to do so.He started the 1910–11 season as a regular, making 7 appearances in 10 games, but lost his place and never really regained it.For a time Chorlton was the club's penalty-taker, which helped him hit 8 goals in his 121 outings for the Anfield club.