 He is the recipient of the 1989 award for Outstanding Achievement in Public Service from the Alliance for Justice; the Weston Howland Jr. Award for Distinguished National Leadership from Tufts University; a Lifetime Achievement Award in 1997 by the National Society of Fundraising Executives; and the 1998 John Gardner Leadership Award sponsored by Independent Sector.In June 2004, he received an honorary Doctor of Laws degree from Princeton University.Eisenberg played in Wimbledon five times, making the quarterfinals in doubles alongside John "Buddy" Ager in 1955.