 This portrayal of Mary Jane could be considered superior to some in the industry, since her clothes don't seem to be actively falling off her".The "Toronto Star"'s Malene Arpe echoed this, pointing to female characters with even more revealing appearances, such as Black Cat and Witchblade.Gary Susman of "Entertainment Weekly" lamented that the statuette was not issued some weeks earlier, so that it could have been included in the website 10 Zen Monkeys' list of "Ten Worst Spiderman Tie-Ins".