 This was subsequently repealed by the Identity Documents Act 2010 during the Conservative–Liberal Democrat coalition of 2010.In 2018 the question was raised again, with articles in "The Economist" and "The Times" considering whether it might help address concerns about citizenship and migration, particularly in the light of the Windrush scandal.At the end of April 2018, two former Home Secretaries Charles Clarke and Alan Johnson called for a rethink on ID cards, saying that immigration targets would be useless without them.