 Andy is at first reluctant but relents at Erin's friendly urging.The hunt starts with a puzzle picture, which leads to Gabe's stereo in Darryl's office, which leads to glow in the dark stars in Ryan's closet, leading to sparkling cider with Hank the security guard, and finally to a Valentine's cookie in the break room.When the cookie tells her to enjoy her Valentine's kiss, Erin thinks she's supposed to kiss Andy.