 Roscioli made her Broadway debut on July 21, 2009, reprising the role of Elphaba in the New York company of the musical.She played her final performance March 21, 2010 and was succeeded by Mandy Gonzalez.Roscioli reprised the role on the show's First National U.S. Tour, with performances from June 7, 2011 to October 2, 2011, replacing Jackie Burns.