 The boys' varsity ice hockey team won Colonial Valley Conference - Valley Division Championships in 2015, 16, 18 and 19.The boys' soccer team won the 2003 NJSIAA Parochial A state sectional championship with a 3–1 win over Notre Dame High School.The Paul VI boys' cross country team had a dual meet unbeaten streak that started in 1979 and ended at 244 straight wins after 28 years.