 With Dundee he also played in the 1924–25 Scottish Cup final in which after leading at half-time, Dundee lost 2–1 to a last minute goal by Celtic's Jimmy McGrory.Halliday scored 90 goals in 126 league appearances for the Dees.Adding 13 goals from 21 Scottish Cup games, he scored 103 goals in 147 Scottish League and cup games for Dundee in 4 seasons.