 The club won the East Region South Division in 2009–10 and then gained promotion to the East Superleague two years later.They spent six seasons in the Superleague, with a best finish of 5th in their final season.After moving to the senior football pyramid for the 2018-19 season, Broxburn won the East of Scotland League Conference C. However they narrowly missed out on the title and promotion to the Lowland league in the round robin playoff against the winners of the other Conferences, Penicuik Athletic and Bonnyrigg Rose.