 Following "Next to Normal's" closing, Chanler-Berat was cast in the role of Boy (Peter) in the Off-Broadway play "Peter and the Starcatcher," based on the book of the same name.The show transferred to Broadway in early 2012, and Chanler-Berat remained with the production until its closing during the January of the next year.After "Peter and the Starcatcher," Chanler-Berat participated in a number of Regional and Off-Broadway productions, including "Fly By Night" as Harold McClam, "The Fortress of Solitude" as Dylan Ebdus, "Sunday in the Park with George" as Georges Seurat, and "Amélie" as Nino, the latter of which transferred to Broadway in 2017.