 Their first post season appearance and title came in 1963 in the Mason Dixon conference playoffs where they defeated Loyola two games to one.While playing in the NCAA's Division II Old Dominion won 6 titles; two Tidewater Scholastic championships in 1932 & 1934, four Little Eight championships in 1958 & 1961-63, and four Mason-Dixon Conference championships in 1963, 1964, 1965, and 1968.In 1963 & 1964 the Monarchs won the NCAA College Division Eastern Championship before losing in the championship in 1965.