 An elegant formal estate was created by Hatch, but he sold out in 1953 to cattleman Theron Bringhurst.The commercial activities of Providence included private mercantile shops of Rice, Hargraves, and Theurer plus a ZCMI Co-op store (1869–1912).Many years after the Co-op structure burned, Watkins and Sons Printing established a business in a remodeled and expanded facility.