 Cult Noise Magazine also reviewed the album, saying it "showcased a new era for Megan & Liz," with the switch from pop to country.Fountain Pen Girl Blog gave the album a 9/10 rating, stating that "Simple Life", Karma's Coming Back for Me", and "New At This" are the highlights, while the other songs can get a bit repetitive at times.Its average rating on iTunes as of June 23, 2014, is 5 stars.