 Out of the twelve finalists, she proceeded to the top four, and she pitched an idea to producers for a potential series called "Stacey's Modern Magic".Although deemed by critics to be a frontrunner for the season, Poon-Kinney was eliminated from the show on , finishing in fourth place.Her elimination was met with anger and surprise by many viewers, and the decision was described as "shocking" by the season's eventual winner, Damaris Phillips.