 Later that year and into the next she toured with E. H. Sothern as Isabel in "If I Were King", a historical drama by Justin Huntly McCarthy.At the Herald Square Theatre in March 1903,Troutman played Annie Bellamy to the Peg Woffington of Grace George in Frances Aymar Mathews’s biographical drama, "Pretty Peggy".She subsequently left the cast of "Pretty Peggy" to play leading rôles with Amelia Bingham's touring company before joining Boston’s Castle Square Theatre the following season as a stock player.