 His current wife, Bethany Tyler, is a former Dallas Cowboys cheerleader.Tinderholt married Kimberly Ann Johnson in 1990, she divorced him in 1994, they remarried in 1995, and she divorced him again in 1996.After their first divorce, Johnson was granted a restraining order against Tinderholt for threatening Johnson, causing her bodily harm/injury, and destroying property shared by the couple.