 Comeau was named to the 2016 Chicago Red Stars final roster, after having been a trialist.On July 16, 2016, in her second start for Chicago Red Stars Taylor Comeau scored a crucial goal in a 1–0 away win over Orlando Pride; which positioned the Red Stars in solitary possession of fourth place in 2016 National Women's Soccer League season putting the team on track to a playoff spot.On June 18, 2018 Comeau was traded alongside Sofia Huerta to the Houston Dash as part of a three team trade that also included the Utah Royals FC 

After being acquired midseason by the Dash, Comeau made her debut for Houston on June 22 against Portland Thorns FC.