 By 1958 the church vestry became concerned, and in 1962 refused to grant permission for any more work to be done on the site.Soon negotiations began to break the original contract; in 1968 the property reverted to the church, and Remey was given five years to remove anything of value from the site.Most of the dead were taken by relatives to another family cemetery in New York; Remey's wife Gertrude was reinterred in the main church cemetery.