 By the 1830s, the stone church was beginning to become structurally unsound, and the current structure, an frame structure that is an example of Greek Revival architecture, although featuring Gothic Revival (Carpenter Gothic) windows, was erected in 1837-1838 at a cost of $2,000.Additions to this structure, largely to support the church's "Sunday school" (children's Christian education) and fellowship activities, were built in 1910, 1959, and 1990.It is likely the third structure used by this congregation—the first presumed to be a rudimentary log building erected circa 1745-1750 that occupied the site in the Stillwater Cemetery of the fieldstone structure which succeeded it.