 In a test case involving an Oakland bar, "Vallerga v. Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control", the California Supreme Court struck down this new law as unconstitutional.This decision was not a complete victory, as the court noted that had the ABC's revocation been based on "reports of women dancing with other women and women kissing other women" it might have upheld the law.Homosexuals, therefore, had won the right to assemble but only if they agreed not to touch.