 Internationally the song was a moderate success peaking within the top 40 at number 30 on the UK official charts on November 22, 1997. on the UK official Dance single chart the song also peaked within the top 40 at number 25 on November 16, 1997.Also on November 16, 1997 the song peaked within the top 5 at number 3 on the UK official R&B charts.Elsewhere in Europe "The One I Gave My Heart To" peaked within the top 20 at number 16 in the Netherlands on the Tipparade chart on February 6, 1998.