 Eventually the song reached it peaked within the top 10 ten weeks later after its first charting at number 8 on December 6, 1997.The song also peaked within the top ten on the Rhythmic charts at number 8 on November 15, 1997.On the Billboard Dance charts the song peaked within the top 20 at number 18 on February 28, 1998. on October 21, 1997 "The One I Gave My Heart To" was certified Gold by the RIAA for sales of over 900,000 copies sold.