 In 2011, McGillivary signed with expansion rivals Niagara United, and his replacement was Carlo Arghittu.The Wolves went through another period of rebuilding under Arghittu, failing to qualify for the postseason during his three-year tenure.In 2012–13, following the controversy faced by the CSL over the Canadian Soccer Association decision to adopt the recommendations from the Rethink Management Report the CSA de-sanctioned the league putting the future of many of its clubs and operations in doubt.