 After their flight to the Bay of Honduras, a frigate was captured to replace the lost "Morning Star" and the two met with success capturing several ships in the Bahamas during the next several months.However, while careening their ships at Tobago in April 1723, they were surprised by the British warship during which Fenn's ship was lost.Forced to run into the wooded interior of Tobago, he was captured a day later and brought back to Antigua where he was found guilty of piracy and hanged with six of his crew the following month.